Choosing the right property management system (PMS) is one of the most important decisions a short-term rental business will make.

If you’re managing more than a handful of listings, the stakes are high: payouts, owner trust, financial accuracy, automation, and scalability all depend on your PMS. Guesty and Hostaway are often the first platforms property managers consider — but they aren’t always the best fit once a business starts to scale.

This guide breaks down Guesty vs Hostaway vs PropertyStack to help professional short-term rental operators choose the right platform for where they are now — and where they’re going next.

‍

Who Each Platform Is Best For

Guesty

Guesty is widely known and packed with features, making it popular with larger property management companies.

Best for:

• Large portfolios (50–200+ listings)
  
• Teams with dedicated ops and accounting staff
  
• Businesses willing to trade simplicity for depth
  

Common challenges:

• Complex setup and onboarding
  
• Expensive as portfolios grow
• Accounting often requires external tools or workarounds

‍

Hostaway

Hostaway focuses on flexibility and integrations, appealing to tech-savvy operators.

Best for:

• Mid-size PMs who want control
  
• Businesses comfortable managing multiple tools
  
• Teams that already have accounting processes in place
  

Common challenges:

• Limited native trust accounting
• Financial reporting can feel bolted-on
• Owners often require manual explanations
  

‍

PropertyStack

PropertyStack was built specifically for professional short-term rental property managers who want clean financials, owner transparency, and room to scale.

Best for:

• PMs managing 10–50+ listings
  
• Businesses scaling beyond spreadsheets
  
• Operators who prioritize trust accounting and owner confidence

‍

Feature Comparison That Actually Matters

‍

Automation vs Operational Control

Both Guesty and Hostaway offer strong automation — but more automation doesn’t always mean better operations.

PropertyStack focuses on:

• Automating what should be automated
  
• Keeping humans in control of finances and payouts
  
• Reducing “automation debt” that creates downstream errors

‍

Owner Reporting & Transparency

Owner trust is fragile — and reporting is where many PMSs fall short.

Platform - Owner Financial Clarity

Guesty - Customizable, but often complex

Hostaway - Functional, often manual

PropertyStack - Built-in, owner-first financial views

PropertyStack treats owners as first-class stakeholders, not an afterthought.

‍

Trust Accounting (The Real Differentiator)

Most PMSs were built for distribution and messaging — not financial compliance.

PropertyStack:

• Separates funds correctly
  
• Tracks owner balances cleanly
  
• Eliminates commingling risks
  
• Simplifies audits and reconciliation
  
  

This becomes non-negotiable as your portfolio grows.

Pricing & Scalability Reality Check

• Guesty pricing increases quickly with scale
  
• Hostaway requires additional tools as complexity grows
  
• PropertyStack consolidates financial workflows, reducing tool sprawl
  
  

The real cost isn’t subscription fees — it’s operational overhead.

Which PMS Should You Choose?

Choose Guesty if:
You’re already operating at enterprise scale and have internal teams to manage complexity.

Choose Hostaway if:
You want flexibility and don’t mind stitching together your own accounting stack.

Choose PropertyStack if:
You’re building a professional, scalable STR business and want financial clarity at the core.

👉 If you’re comparing PMS options, PropertyStack was built for exactly this stage of growth.

‍